Beyond the Price: Can Humanity Grow Past Monetization, and How Would It Do That Together?
Cite this paper
SomaSoft Research (prepared by Claude Code for the AURI project). (2026-11-19). "Beyond the Price: Can Humanity Grow Past Monetization, and How Would It Do That Together?". SomaSoft Research. https://somasoft.ai/papers/beyond-the-price. Licensed under SAGL-1.0.
SomaSoft is a research project, not a product: no users, no deployments. Nothing here is medical, legal or financial advice. Limits and corrections
Beyond the Price
Can humanity grow past monetization, and how would it do that together?
Draft, 19 November 2026. Not peer reviewed. A companion to "The Direction of Intelligence."
1. The wrong question and a better one
"Can humanity grow beyond monetization?" usually turns into an argument between two camps. One holds that markets are how people cooperate at scale and anything else is naive. The other holds that money corrodes whatever it touches and should be overcome.
Both camps are partly right, and both answer the wrong question. The useful question is not whether money should exist. It is which parts of life money should govern, who decides, and what happens to the boundary when a technology makes a great deal of work suddenly cheap. This paper takes that question in four steps:
- what already runs without money (section 2);
- what pricing does to some things (section 3);
- why artificial intelligence makes the boundary urgent (section 4);
- how the boundary could be redrawn collaboratively instead of by whoever moves first (sections 5–6).
2. A large part of life already runs without prices
The non-monetized economy is not a utopian proposal. It is most of daily life.
- Care. The International Labour Organization estimates that people do 16.4 billion hours of unpaid care work every day, based on data from 64 countries. Valued at an hourly minimum wage, that is about US$11 trillion, or 9% of global GDP (ILO, 2018). Raising children, looking after the sick and the old, and keeping households running mostly sit outside markets. Markets depend on them anyway.
- Knowledge. Wikipedia is written by volunteers and run by a nonprofit, the Wikimedia Foundation. Much of the software the internet runs on is open source. Benkler (2006) called this commons-based peer production: people cooperating without relying on either market signals or managerial commands.
- Commons. Ostrom (1990) documented grazing land, forests, fisheries and irrigation systems that communities had governed for generations, in some cases for centuries, often better than standard theory predicted, without either privatisation or central control. That work earned her a share of the 2009 Nobel prize in economics, "for her analysis of economic governance, especially the commons".
- Everyday mutual help. Graeber (2011) called the habit of helping without keeping accounts "baseline communism": giving according to need and ability, not in exchange. People hand over a tool, give directions, or share food with a neighbour without sending a bill. On his view it underlies every economy, including the most capitalist.
So the honest answer to "can humanity live beyond monetization?" is that it already does, much of the time. The real question is why this sphere keeps shrinking and whether that is wise.
3. Pricing sometimes destroys what it measures
Markets are very good at some jobs:
- coordinating strangers who have no reason to trust each other;
- signalling what is scarce;
- letting millions of separate decisions add up without a central planner.
For other goods, attaching a price changes what the thing is. Three studies show this.
- Blood. Titmuss (1970) compared the largely commercial blood supply of the United States with the voluntary system in England and Wales, and argued that paid blood carried a higher risk of transmitting hepatitis. Payment changed who gave and why. His comparison helped push the United States toward voluntary donation.
- Daycare fines. Gneezy and Rustichini (2000) studied ten private daycare centres in Haifa, Israel. Six introduced a fine for parents who arrived more than ten minutes late to collect their children; four served as controls. Late pickups rose. The fine turned a moral obligation into a fee people could pay. When the fine was removed, lateness stayed high: the obligation did not come back.
- A nuclear-waste site. Frey and Oberholzer-Gee (1997) surveyed residents of two Swiss communities in 1993 (305 interviews) about hosting a nuclear-waste repository. 50.8% said they would accept it. When the same question came with annual compensation for every resident, acceptance fell to 24.6%, and raising the amount made no significant difference. The authors read this as civic duty being crowded out: the offer of money implied the matter was a deal, not a duty, and people turned the deal down.
Economists call this motivation crowding-out. Sandel (2012) made the wider argument: some goods are corrupted, not merely redistributed, by being bought and sold. Polanyi (1944) made the historical version. He argued that treating land, labour and money as ordinary commodities provokes society to defend itself, sometimes violently.
The other extreme has failed too. Attempts to remove money and markets from economic life altogether, through comprehensive central planning, produced shortages, waste and, in the worst cases, catastrophe. The evidence supports neither "price everything" nor "price nothing". It supports a market with boundaries, chosen deliberately.
4. Why cheap intelligence makes the boundary urgent
Keynes (1930) predicted that his grandchildren would face a strange problem: abundance, with too little necessary work, and suggested "three-hour shifts or a fifteen-hour week" to share what remained. The abundance he expected partly arrived. The leisure did not, and the gains were not evenly shared.
Machine intelligence raises the same question more sharply. If writing, analysis, translation, tutoring, code and routine advice become close to free to produce, two things follow:
- Abundant goods are hard to sell. Once something can be copied at almost no cost, the market price tends toward zero. Value then gets captured somewhere else: through ownership of the platform, the data, the computing power or the customer relationship.
- What is hard to sell is easy to enclose. Historically, abundance has often been turned back into scarcity: common land fenced off, open standards replaced by proprietary ones, free services funded by selling attention. The same can happen to AI, through a few providers who sit between people and the capability and charge rent for access.
So AI does not settle the monetization question. It forces it. The gains from cheap cognition will go either mostly to whoever controls distribution, or broadly to people, depending on structures being set up now: licensing, ownership, data rights, and who sits on which board.
In an earlier reply to another paper (October 2026), we argued that concentration increasingly runs through distribution and connectors rather than model ownership. That is the enclosure path. It is not inevitable, but it is the default if no one chooses otherwise.
5. Six collaborative steps
None of these is new. Each has working precedents. The contribution here is to put them together and say how each applies when the abundant good is intelligence.
Step 1: Decide on purpose what stays outside the market
Societies already keep some things out of markets: votes, organs, children, jury verdicts. AI needs a similar list, agreed openly rather than left to terms of service. Candidates:
- children's attention and data;
- help during a health or safety crisis (a person in danger should never meet a paywall or an upsell);
- civic participation: the right to understand, deliberate and vote without being targeted;
- intimate personal data: health, relationships, beliefs;
- basic knowledge: the shared record of what humanity knows.
The test is the crowding-out evidence from section 3. Where pricing a good is likely to change what it is, keep it out of the market and fund it some other way.
Step 2: Govern shared resources as commons, with rules
"Open" is not enough. An open resource with no rules gets over-used or captured. Ostrom (1990) found that commons which lasted shared eight design principles, including:
- clear boundaries;
- rules suited to local conditions, made by the people they affect;
- monitoring by people accountable to the users;
- penalties that escalate gradually;
- cheap ways to resolve conflict;
- recognition by outside authorities.
Open AI models, open datasets and shared evaluation suites are commons. They need the same institutions: licences that bind use, stewards who can be held to account, and a way for contributors to have a say.
Step 3: Share the surplus by design
When a shared resource produces wealth, mechanisms already exist that return the wealth to people instead of concentrating it.
- Alaska's Permanent Fund has paid every eligible resident an annual dividend since 1982, from a fund built on oil revenue.
- Norway's Government Pension Fund Global manages oil and gas revenue over the long term for current and future generations.
- Cooperatives distribute surplus to members. Mondragon in Spain employs tens of thousands of people under that model.
- Sesame Workshop is a nonprofit that funds research-based children's education through a mix of licensing, distribution fees and donations. Its programme has moved between distributors (PBS, then HBO from 2016, then Netflix alongside PBS from 2025) without giving up its purpose.
An AI-era version would put a share of the gains from shared models and data into funds that no single company controls. Our own research on cooperative and civic structures (SomaSoft, 2026) adds a warning. Ownership alone has often failed to protect a mission once serious money appeared; mutual societies and cooperatives have been sold off by their own members. What held more often was a party with a veto and nothing to gain from a sale, plus rules that bind what is produced.
Step 4: Count contribution that is not paid
If unpaid care is worth about 9% of world GDP and does not appear in it, then policies guided by GDP will keep under-supporting it. As AI takes over more paid work, the share of valuable human activity that is unpaid will probably grow: care, teaching, community work, maintenance, art.
Practical options include:
- satellite accounts that measure unpaid work alongside GDP;
- pension and social-insurance credit for care work;
- AI systems designed to support this work (scheduling, information, relief) rather than replace the relationship at its centre.
Step 5: Give the people affected a voice
Hirschman (1970) distinguished exit (leaving) from voice (speaking up and being heard). Markets are built on exit: if you don't like the product, switch. When a few providers dominate, exit stops working, and only voice remains.
Deliberation at scale has a record of working:
- Ireland's Citizens' Assembly (2016–18) brought together randomly selected citizens to deliberate on contested questions. Its 2017 recommendations on abortion led to a referendum in May 2018 that passed with 66.4% of the vote.
- Polis, open-source software from the Computational Democracy Project, works differently from a poll or a comment thread.
- Participants write short statements and vote agree, disagree or pass on other people's statements.
- The software maps where opinion groups form.
- It surfaces the statements that win support across groups.
- There is no reply button, so there is no thread to derail.
- vTaiwan, a consultation process begun in 2014, first used Polis in 2015 on how to regulate Uber. The government agreed to take up the points of consensus, although the wider dispute over ride-hailing was not settled by it.
- Collective Constitutional AI (2023) used Polis to ask about 1,000 Americans to propose and vote on principles for an AI model; they wrote 1,127 statements and cast 38,252 votes. A model trained on the public's principles was then compared with one trained on the company's own.
Deliberation like this is the most direct answer to "how should this progress collaboratively?" The boundaries in step 1, the commons rules in step 2 and the fund design in step 3 should be drafted with the people affected, not for them.
Step 6: Start small and measure
Large visions of post-monetary society have a poor record. Small working institutions have a good one. A five-person cooperative that functions teaches more than a manifesto does. Each step above should be tried at small scale with a measure of whether it worked, including whether people were actually better off, and the result published even if it is a failure.
6. What this project is doing, and not doing
We should apply the paper's standard to ourselves. SomaSoft is a one-founder LLC with no revenue and no users.
| Step | What exists | What does not |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Things kept out of the market | The papers, the corrections record and the research are free to read. The draft safety core bars collecting data from children without a guardian's written consent. | No public list of what we will never monetize. |
| 2. Commons with rules | Papers are released under a source-available licence (SAGL), with obligations on commercial users. | SAGL's commercial terms have no acceptance step yet, so their enforceability is untested. Counsel review is pending. |
| 3. Shared surplus | A benefit fund is proposed. A term sheet for counsel would move it out of our control. | No fund account exists. The holder and the rate are undecided. |
| 4. Unpaid contribution | AURIX is designed as a care companion, not a substitute caregiver. | No measurement of whether it helps any carer. |
| 5. Voice | A Polis-style consultation on the project's principles is proposed in our research report on cooperative and civic structures. | Not run. No outside person has a say in our direction yet. |
| 6. Small, measured trials | A blinded user study is drafted. | Zero evaluated sessions with real people. |
The right-hand column is longer than the left. That is the honest state of the project.
7. Limits
- This is an argument, not a forecast. No society has faced cheap cognitive labour at this scale, so how the boundary will move is unknown.
- The crowding-out studies are specific. Each covers one setting, and crowding-out does not happen everywhere. In other settings, payment increases helpful behaviour. The claim is that it can happen and should be checked, not that it always does.
- The precedents are selected. We chose successful commons, funds and deliberations. Many others failed. Ostrom's principles describe what the lasting ones share; they do not promise success.
- Polis and citizens' assemblies have known limits. These include who turns up, how statements are seeded, and whether decision-makers act on the results. They make deliberation possible; they do not ensure it is acted on.
- Our own column in section 6 is self-reported and should be checked against the dated public record.
8. Conclusion
Humanity does not need to abolish money to grow beyond it. It already lives partly beyond it, in care, knowledge, commons and ordinary reciprocity. Some of these are damaged by being priced, and the damage can outlast the price.
Machine intelligence will make much of what is now sold close to free. That opens two paths:
- enclosure: abundance turned back into scarcity by whoever controls access;
- a commons: abundance shared under rules people help to write.
The difference will come from choices made now: what we agree to keep out of markets, how shared resources are governed, where the surplus goes, whether unpaid contribution is counted, and whether the people affected get a voice.
That voice cannot be designed by the builders alone. Tools now exist that let thousands of people find where they agree, and the boundary of the market should be drawn with them.
References
- Anthropic & Collective Intelligence Project (2023, 17 October). Collective Constitutional AI: Aligning a Language Model with Public Input. anthropic.com/research. Full paper: Huang, S. et al. (2024), arXiv:2406.07814.
- Benkler, Y. (2006). The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom. Yale University Press.
- Computational Democracy Project. Polis (open-source deliberation software). pol.is; compdemocracy.org
- Frey, B. S. & Oberholzer-Gee, F. (1997). The cost of price incentives: an empirical analysis of motivation crowding-out. American Economic Review 87(4), 746–755.
- Gneezy, U. & Rustichini, A. (2000). A fine is a price. Journal of Legal Studies 29(1), 1–17.
- Graeber, D. (2011). Debt: The First 5,000 Years. Melville House.
- Hirschman, A. O. (1970). Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States. Harvard University Press.
- International Labour Organization (2018). Care Work and Care Jobs for the Future of Decent Work. Geneva: ILO.
- Ireland, Referendum Commission (2018). Referendum on the Thirty-sixth Amendment of the Constitution Bill 2018: results. referendum.ie
- Keynes, J. M. (1930). Economic possibilities for our grandchildren. The Nation and Athenaeum, 11 and 18 October 1930; reprinted in Essays in Persuasion (1931).
- Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge University Press.
- Polanyi, K. (1944). The Great Transformation. Farrar & Rinehart.
- Sandel, M. J. (2012). What Money Can't Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- SomaSoft Research (2026). Cooperative and civic structures for AGI (research report, unpublished).
- SomaSoft Research (2026). The Direction of Intelligence: Choosing Your Direction, somasoft.ai/papers/the-direction-of-intelligence.
- Titmuss, R. M. (1970). The Gift Relationship: From Human Blood to Social Policy. Allen & Unwin.
AURI's own systems were queried on this topic on 2026-11-19 ("Can people cooperate without money?"). They returned only a dictionary definition at confidence 0.212, so nothing in this paper comes from AURI. References and factual claims were checked against published sources on 2026-11-22.